Use: 20OFFREALESTATE Save up 20% on all Corofy Real Estate courses. Ends June 26, 2024.

Can A Realtor In NYC Lie About Multiple Offers?

corofy real estate school new york
In this article

In the fast-paced real estate market of New York City, the competition among buyers could be fierce, with multiple offers on a single property sometimes being a common scenario. Understandably, as a buyer or seller, you might question the veracity of claims made by realtors about multiple offers on a property. It’s pivotal to recognize that while realtors aim to facilitate a sale to the benefit of all parties involved, there may be instances where the truth about multiple offers is stretched to create a sense of urgency or to drive up the sale price.

A realtor in NYC confidently states multiple offers on a property, while a skeptical buyer looks through paperwork and raises an eyebrow

Navigating the NYC real estate landscape requires awareness of both the ethical standards that realtors are expected to uphold and the legal frameworks in place that discourage misinformation. Knowing the motivations behind misrepresenting multiple offers and being equipped with strategies to verify such claims can support your integrity and protect your interests during transactions. It’s essential to engage in this dialogue with a realistic understanding of the market dynamics and a solid grounding in the legalities that govern real estate practices in New York.

Key Takeaways

  • Realtors may misrepresent multiple offers to increase competition.
  • There are ethical and legal guidelines in NYC to prevent such conduct.
  • Verify the validity of multiple offers to safeguard your real estate interests.

Why Would a Realtor Want to Lie About Multiple Offers?

A realtor's office with a desk cluttered with papers and a computer screen showing multiple property listings. A phone is ringing off the hook and the realtor looks stressed

In the competitive world of New York City real estate, a realtor may be tempted to misrepresent the truth about receiving multiple offers on a property to create urgency and drive up the offer amount.

Get a Higher Bid

When you’re attempting to purchase a home, the existence of other potential buyers can introduce a heightened sense of competition. Realtors know that if you believe there are multiple offers for the property you’re interested in, you might be inclined to submit a higher bid to beat the competition. This strategy aims to initiate a bidding war, increasing the home sale price—and subsequently, the commission the realtor stands to earn.

Crucially, though, this tactic conflicts with the Realtor Code of Ethics, which requires realtors to act in good faith and deal honestly with all parties involved in a real estate transaction. Encouraging you to push your budget to make your best and final offer might secure the home for you, but it should be conducted with genuine offers to ensure the process is fair and ethical. Nevertheless, the competitive energy of knowing others are interested can push not just towards a higher offer amount but expedite your decision to negotiate, sometimes beyond what is comfortable or financially prudent.

Are There Laws Against Realtors Lying About Multiple Offers in NYC?

In New York City, the real estate industry is governed by strict regulations and a clear code of ethics designed to ensure fair practices. Specifically, when you’re considering making an offer on a property, it’s critical to understand that there are state laws and Realtor association rules that address the honesty of real estate agents.

Firstly, it’s important for you to know that New York State agency laws require agents to provide an agency disclosure form to buyers. This form outlines the agent’s fiduciary duty to their client, which includes the obligation to act honestly.

The National Association of Realtors (NAR), which sets the standard nationwide, has a Code of Ethics that its members must follow. According to this code, Realtors are prohibited from deliberately misleading or lying about the status of offers. If a Realtor is found in violation of these standards, they may face legal trouble, including fines, suspension, or removal from the association.

Bear in mind, these regulations and ethical codes are there to protect your interests in a business transaction. While these safeguards are in place, proving dishonesty can be challenging. If you suspect that an agent has lied about multiple offers, it is within your right to report them to the local real estate board for investigation. This action reinforces the integrity of the buying and selling process in the highly competitive NYC real estate market.

Your understanding of these regulations can empower you in your real estate endeavors, ensuring that the business conducted by parties on all sides remains within the bounds of the law and ethics codes set forth by governing bodies.

Do Realtors Have Any Other Regulations Against Lying?

When engaging in real estate transactions in New York City, realtors are bound not only by legal standards but also by a strict code of ethics that aims to ensure honest and transparent communication. These regulations and ethical obligations are especially pivotal when disclosing offers on a real estate listing to avoid any deceptive practices.

With Approval from the Seller

Your real estate transaction is safeguarded by several layers of regulations that prohibit realtors from lying. Primarily, the Realtor Code of Ethics dictates that realtors must act with honesty toward all parties in the transaction. This means they are required to present all offers truthfully, without misrepresentation, to the seller.

Real estate listing agents and cooperating brokers must adhere to these ethical standards, as a violation could lead to severe consequences, including the revocation of their license. Furthermore, confidentiality remains paramount; your real estate attorney will guide you regarding the legal requisites for disclosing offers, ensuring your interests are maintained without breaching any regulatory conditions.

Another vital New York City-specific regulation comes from the Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY), which mandates transparency in the communication of real estate transactions. A realtor, including the listing broker, needs to have explicit approval from the seller when handling multiple offers and communicating these to any prospective buyers or their agents.

This is essential to note since buyer agent commission rebates and other financial incentives can affect the nature of offers. Your realtor must provide you with clear, factual information, and anything less could be grounds for reporting to authorities. Always seek accounting advice to understand the full implications of any communicated offer in your interactions with realtors.

How to Avoid Getting Caught Up in the Multiple Offer Lie

When navigating the New York City real estate market, it’s crucial to discern the truth about multiple offers on a property to ensure you’re making well-informed decisions.

Asking for the Information Outright

To help validate the existence of multiple offers, simply ask the seller’s agent to provide proof. Although sellers are under no obligation to disclose the details of other offers, some agents may be willing to confirm the number of offers they’ve received. You can request a signed confidentiality agreement before viewing any sensitive information, which may include accepted offers or earnest money checks. Bear in mind, the details of the negotiation process are usually kept private to maintain fair competition.

Don’t Get Too Attached to One Property

Maintaining a level of detachment to any single property can be beneficial. This mindset allows you to better handle the situation if you are presented with the news of multiple offers. Having a backup offer ready for another property can also alleviate the pressure to win at all costs, making it easier for you to walk away if the offer does not remain negotiable or if the auction process seems suspicious. Your buyer’s agent can be invaluable during this time, providing guidance and keeping your chances in check by analyzing whether an offer aligns with the current market conditions.


In New York City, while realtors are expected to adhere to a strict code of ethics, the reality is that proving dishonesty regarding multiple offers can be challenging. The repercussions for realtors who are found to have lied about multiple offers can be significant, including legal ramifications and damage to their professional reputation. As a buyer, it’s essential to consider the integrity of the information received.

  • Verify Claims: It’s prudent to request proof of multiple offers, if possible.
  • Professional Guidance: Seek out a reputable real estate professional who values transparency.
  • Legal Framework: Familiarize yourself with New York State laws that govern real estate practices.

Your vigilance and due diligence are crucial in navigating the competitive landscape of New York City real estate transactions. Remember that the majority of realtors operate with integrity, valuing their reputation and long-term relationships with clients.

Frequently Asked Questions

Navigating the complexities of the New York City real estate market often involves dealing with multiple offers on a property. The following questions address your concerns about the legality and ethics of real estate agents presenting offers.

Is it legal for real estate agents to fabricate offers on a property?

Legally, real estate agents must adhere to a strict code of ethics and fabrication of offers is a violation. In New York City, such conduct would be considered deceptive and against the industry’s guidelines.

What steps can be taken if you suspect a realtor of making false claims about multiple offers?

If you suspect a realtor of dishonesty, you should report the behavior to the local real estate board. In NYC, the Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) can be a resource for filing complaints and initiating investigations into unethical practices.

Are there consequences for realtors presenting fake offers to potential buyers?

Yes, there are consequences. Real estate agents found presenting fake offers could face sanctions from their governing boards, reputational damage, and loss of their license in severe cases.

How can buyers verify the authenticity of competing offers mentioned by a realtor?

Buyers can ask the realtor for proof of the competing offers in a form that does not violate the confidentiality of the other potential buyers. Documentation or written confirmation could serve as verification.

What is the most common complaint filed against realtors concerning the disclosure of offers?

One common complaint is that realtors mislead buyers about the existence of other offers to create a false sense of urgency or to drive up the offer price. This practice is both unethical and misleading for potential buyers.

Under what circumstances could a real estate agent face legal action for misrepresentation of offers?

Legal action could ensue if a real estate agent knowingly lies about the existence of other offers, as this constitutes fraud. Consequences are particularly severe when such misrepresentations lead to financial losses for the buyer.

Who is Corofy?

Before being a school, Corofy is a community. Our founder, Eddy Boccara, started his real estate career as a real estate salesperson looking for a side hustle.

Since then, he’s had a passion for New York real estate and specifically the talented individuals that take the leap to get their real estate license and help this industry progress.

Eddy created Corofy with one goal in mind: to provide people with quality real estate education that actually helps them build a career they can be proud of.

New York Online 77-hour Real Estate Pre-Licensing Course

Engaging Online Real Estate Course Content

Our New York online real estate course is designed to help you stay engaged and pass the New York real estate exam. With this in mind, our pre-licensing course includes:

Fun activities & quizzes

Chapter review summaries

Easy to follow content

Careers tips and advice

Memory cues to help you learn